GTA 6 MISSION CHOICES
Short answer: so far, the choices don't change the story. They change small things, like a payout or an item. Here is every choice players have reported in launch week, what each option gets you, and which one to pick. Light spoilers for Chapters 1 to 3.
| Donnie or Brian? | Donnie, before Swamped |
|---|---|
| Kill or spare Arnold? | Doesn't matter |
| Cut or Pure? | Pure, $1,500 |
| Give Halifax the statue? | Yes, for the watch |
Based on early player walkthroughs from launch week (sources below), not on anything Rockstar has published. We will update this page as players get further.
DONNIE OR BRIAN (CHAPTER 1)
Early in Chapter 1 you can fence drugs with either Brian Heder (unlocked by Lab Fees) or Donnie (unlocked by Clean Up After Donnie). The question comes up in two side missions: Find the Lost Drugs, where you search the swamps for packages and sell them to either fence, and Donnie's Lost Drugs, where you dive on Donnie's sunken boat off Corsair Key and can sell the bag at Brian's Lockup for $1,200.
Pick Donnie for narcotics. He pays more than Brian in Chapter 1, and Brian pays later rather than on the spot. Do it before the mission Swamped: both stop buying after Chapter 1, and from Chapter 2 Dunk in Port Gellhorn takes over. Every fence and what pays.
HEY ARNOLD! (CHAPTER 1)
Brian sends Jason and Cal to Maroon Key after his broker Arnold stops answering. At the docks you choose to shoot Arnold or let him go. Players report no difference: he leaves the game either way, Brian treats the problem as settled, the next mission (Island Dreams) opens, and neither choice pays or unlocks anything.
DEALER'S CHOICE (CHAPTER 3)
Dre'Quan sends Jason on a deal and you pick Cut or Pure product. Pure sells without trouble and pays $1,500. Cut can be pushed at half price and leads to the buyers coming back. Walkthroughs report that neither choice changes your money or later missions in a lasting way, and no trophy is tied to it. Finish the handover without violence for a Professional bonus.
DUBIOUS PROVENANCE (CHAPTER 3)
Jason and Lucia take a statue to an antique store in Capri. The owner won't touch it, but dealer Benedict Halifax offers to appraise it and leaves his watch as collateral. Give him the statue: you get the Crowex Octane "Bobby Ambrose" watch (wear it from Accessories > Watches at a wardrobe), and Parts 2 and 3 of the mission stay open. At the end you catch Halifax and choose to shoot or spare him. Players report both work out.
STILL BEING CHECKED
Players have also flagged choices in Pipework (Chapter 1), Afternoon Delight and the Eddie Acosta party (whether to pay $50,000). We haven't seen enough reports to say what they change yet. Know? Post it in the community.
JASON AND LUCIA: OFFICIAL ART
Posts from Rockstar Games' official Instagram (@rockstargames), shown with Instagram's embed. All images © Rockstar Games.
More official GTA VI images on Rockstar's own site: artwork and wallpapers and the launch gallery.
Watch
More GTA VI videos
Videos by YouTube creators, credited on every card. They belong to their creators, not grandtheftauto.gg.
Keep exploring
More GTA VI guides
Bugs and PatchesEvery update so far, known launch issues and the fixes that work on PS5 and Xbox.
Cheats61 cheats after the story: how to unlock and enter them, and the codes confirmed so far.
PC VersionIs GTA 6 on PC? What Take-Two has said, past PC gaps and how to play on a PC screen now.
NewsEvery confirmed update, newest first, with sources.FAQ
Do choices matter in GTA 6?
The choices players have reached so far mostly don't change the story. They change small things: a reward, a watch, or who you sell to. Rockstar has said Jason and Lucia's relationship responds to how you treat it, but no mission choice so far has been reported to change the ending.
Should you sell to Donnie or Brian in GTA 6?
Donnie, for narcotics. In Chapter 1 Donnie pays more than Brian for drugs, and Brian pays later rather than on the spot. Sell to Donnie before the mission Swamped, because Brian and Donnie stop being fences after Chapter 1.
Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
It doesn't matter. Either way Arnold leaves the game, Brian treats the problem as solved, and neither option pays anything.
Cut or Pure in Dealer's Choice?
Pure is the simple option: it sells without trouble for $1,500. Players report that neither option changes your money or later missions in a lasting way.
Should you give Halifax the statue?
Yes. Giving Benedict Halifax the statue gets you his Crowex Octane 'Bobby Ambrose' watch and keeps Parts 2 and 3 of Dubious Provenance open. Shooting or sparing him at the end both work out.
Sources (8)
- GTABase: Donnie's Lost Drugs ($1,200 at Brian's Lockup)
- PowerPyx: Find the Lost Drugs (sell to Brian or Donnie)
- MetaForge: which fence pays best, and when Brian and Donnie stop
- PC Gamer: GTA 6 fence locations and unlock missions
- eGamers: Hey Arnold! choice
- eGamers: Dealer's Choice, Cut or Pure
- GTABase: Dubious Provenance walkthrough
- eGamers: Dubious Provenance, statue and Halifax
We only state what Rockstar, Take-Two, Sony or Microsoft have confirmed, or what is clearly labelled as reported. Spot a mistake? Tell us.
